Detention by non state armed groups in non international armed conflicts. Various treaties have been drafted or revised to regulate states and armed groups party to such conflicts. The international community has acknowledged the importance of engaging ansas on compliance with international norms to any effort to. The application of international humanitarian law to nonstate. Today, the majority of armed conflicts are waged within the state boundaries resulting in much destruction, ruin and victims. Philip jessups legacy and beyond math noortmann part ii 5. Non state actors and the use of force christian henderson 6. International humanitarian law, international human rights law and the question of right authority in ezequiel heffes, marcos d. Unique in examining international humanitarian law, international human rights law, and international criminal law. International humanitarian law and nonstate actors springerlink. Human rights obligations of armed non state actors an exploration of the practice of the n human rights council 4 human rights abuses and violations of international humanitarian law by ansas. Should they be held to the same standards as states during warfare. Back volumes 2004 and 2005 of both journals as well as online issues are still available. The wars of this era are being fought by and against nonstate actors.
About non state actors in international law the role and position of non state actors in international law is the subject of a longstanding and intensive scholarly debate. It is currently focusing its efforts on banning the use of antipersonnel mines, protecting children from the effects of armed conflict, prohibiting sexual violence in armed conflict, working towards the elimination of gender discrimination and building armed non state actors knowledge and implementation of broad. Apr 24, 2019 detention by non state armed groups in non international armed conflicts. Applicability of international humanitarian law to nonstate actors. Its headquarters are situated in villa ormond, sanremo italy. Non state actors and the international rule of law. Ansas in hrc resolutions types of armed nonstate actors a range of ansas operate today in armed conflicts or other situations of violence, but one can find very few definitions of the term in international law. Compliance with international humanitarian law by nonstate.
States jealously guard their lawmaking powers as a key attribute of statehood, making them generally resistant to the idea of sharing such powers with any. Simply, selfinterest is the key factor advanced by realism. The threat to human rights posed by nonstate actors is of increasing concern. Eu, ecowas, and non state actors such as non governmental organizations ngos, rebel groups, and private entities. This book challenges the traditional approach to international law by concentrating on international hthis book challenges the traditional approach to international law by concentrating on international humanitarian law and placing the focus beyond states. Noting, first, the challenges that a growing and diverse group of non state actors pose for. Analyses a wide variety of non state actors, including criminal gangs, transnational armed groups, local communities, and often overlooked cyber criminals. Caseymaslen international law and armed nonstate actors in afghanistan. The term armed groups is not defined in treaty law. Throughout history, civilians have been targeted by belligerents, who often have made no distinction between combatants and civilians when fighting their enemies.
This book explores the participation of this new category of actors in an international legal system that has historically been dominated by states. As the great english bard william shakespeare wrote, all the worlds a stage. The responsibilities and obligations of the nonstate actors. International humanitarian law and nonstate actors youtube. Detention by nonstate armed groups in noninternational. Vnsas vary widely in their goals, size, and methods. More than a glossary, a to z provides definitions of key terms followed by references to relevant parts of the law and the law in practice sections where the terms appear, and to the relevant rules of ihl. Ihl and humanitarian assistance involving nonstate armed. While talking about non state actors may be a non starter in respect of a number of branches of public international law, this is undeniably not so in international humanitarian law ihl. How the war against isis changed international law. Enhancing compliance with international law by armed non.
Zreconceptualizing the rule of law as an international norm. Violations of international humanitarian law by nonstate. Humanitarian principles govern humanitarian actors conduct. Nonstate armed groups, international humanitarian law, conflict. Having considered the reports of the committee on nonstate actors and international law. Non state actors and international obligations examines the contribution and relevance of non state actors in the creation and implementation of international obligations. And the world stage has many players upon it engaged in the great game of international affairs. The icrcs humanitarian diplomacy consists chiefly in making the. Nonstate actors are non sovereign entities that exercise significant economic, political, or social power and influence at a national, and in some cases international, level. Contemporary armed conflicts are characterised by an increase of violence against civilians and a lack of compliance with international humanitarian law ihl by both states and armed non state actors ansas. Nonstate actors and international humanitarian law.
Nonstate actors and accountability in international law. Nonstate actors and international obligations creation. Noting, first, the challenges that a growing and diverse group of nonstate actors pose for. Nonstate actors in international law in policy perspective eisuke suzuki 4. This is the introductory chapter to the book international humanitarian law and non state actors. Since the mid1990s, ihl has expanded its coverage of non international armed conflicts.
International humanitarian law and nonstate practice in. The functions and interactions of nonstate actors in the realm of international humanitarian law. Geneva call is a non governmental organization based in geneva, switzerland. Admittedly, ihl was historically geared toward regulating warfare between states, and it paid only scant attention to the interests of nonstate actors. Chronology of cases and documents relating to past and contemporary conflicts. The article also provides more general remarks on the law of state responsibility as it pertains to acts of non state actors. Human rights obligations of nonstate actors in conflict. Waseem ahmad qureshi follow this and additional works at. While the applicability of common article 3 of the 1949 geneva conventions to the conflict is not controversial, how and to what extent.
The law of international responsibility operates on the basis of a presumption that the conduct of individuals and non state actors is not attributable to a state. This includes ongoing liaison and negotiation with non state armed groups. This chapter will cover international humanitarian law ihl, the binding rules and customs that govern armed conflict between nations, civil war combatants, and conflicts among states and non state belligerents. Admittedly, ihl was historically geared toward regulating warfare between states, and it paid only scant attention to the interests of non state actors. International humanitarian law and nonstate actors. Humanitarian negotiations office for the coordination of. To support these propositions this article will first illustrate the humanitarian concerns. The role and position of non state actors in international law is the subject of a longstanding and intensive scholarly debate. Download pdf humanrightsandnonstateactors free online. Non state actors and international law the 77th conference of the international law association, held in johannesburg, south africa, 7 11 august 2016. While the applicability of common article 3 of the 1949 geneva conventions to the conflict is not controversial, how and to what extent additional protocol ii applies is more difficult to assess, in particular.
International humanitarian law and nonstate actors debates. In international relations, violent non state actors vnsa, also known as non state armed actors or non state armed groups nsags, are individuals and groups that are wholly or partly independent of state governments and which threaten or use violence to achieve their goals. Yearbook of international humanitarian law, vol 19. Dec 17, 2010 should non state armed groups be excluded from the formal realm of international humanitarian law. I contend that the international community should agree to a generalisable rule for the treatment of fighters. The options open to development actors for engagement with nsags non state armed groups can be roughly categorized as follows. While talking about nonstate actors may be a nonstarter in respect of a number of branches of public international law, this is undeniably not so in international humanitarian law ihl. Moreover, the term non state actor refers to all actors. Its main objective is the promotion and dissemination of international humanitarian law, human rights, refugee law and migration law. Non state actors and international humanitarian law. The international institute of humanitarian law is an independent, non profit humanitarian organisation founded in 1970.
Human rights obligations of armed nonstate actors an exploration of the practice of the n human rights council 7 1. Developments in climate change and environmental law in this era have catalyzed innovative governance approaches by non state actors and international organizations. The egregious crimes committed by some non state armed groups can also encourage those who. These actors have traditionally been marginalised within international law and ambiguities remain over their precise role.
Customary international law has gone through a similar expansion roberts and sivakumaran, 2012. Notwithstanding significant advancement in the international legal regulation of armed conflicts between states, it should. The responsibilities and obligations of the nonstate. In the last few decades, the role and status of armed nonstate actors ansa have become essential. The options open to development actors for engagement with nsags nonstate armed groups can be roughly categorized as follows. International law is no longer conceived of as regulating the rights and obligations of states alone, yet any suggestion that nonstate actors could or should play a role in the creation of international law remains highly controversial. While the government is unable to implement and enforce rules and decisions because the state has lost its monopoly over the means of force1, the rise of armed, violent non state actors collides with the state centric traditional nature of public international law. Depending on the context and intended outcomes, engagement with these different actors can take several negotiation with. International humanitarian law and just war theory and ask what the right legal framework is for addressing the threat posed by non state actors in current asymmetric conflict. In a security landscape characterised by the changing nature of armed conflicts and the proliferation of non state actors, the problem of the applicability and enforcement of international humanitarian law poses a number. Pdf ensuring compliance by nonstate actors with rules. Part of the international humanitarian law commons repository citation. This view was not, however, accepted by russia, china, or even the united kingdom. Non state actors under international humanitarian law.
The role of nonstate entities in developing and promoting. This gives explanation to the lack of recognition of international humanitarian law on the part of state actors and non state actors. An effective legal regime governing the actions of armed nonstate actors in. General statements on international humanitarian law.
They may include narcotics cartels, popular liberation movements. Dissertations program on international law and armed. Applicability of international humanitarian law to nonstate. Protection of civilians under international humanitarian law. Download citation non state actors and international humanitarian law treaties on international humanitarian law the geneva conventions and their protocols in particular contain. It will argue that violent non state actors are more properly thought of as international criminals than as combatants of any sort. This book challenges the traditional approach to international law by concentrating on international humanitarian law and placing the focus beyond states. Pdf enhancing compliance with international law by armed. Applicability of international humanitarian law to non state actors dr. He further explained that states have the obligation to respect and ensure. An effective legal regime governing the actions of armed non state actors in afghanistan should encompass not only international humanitarian law but also international human rights law.
From 2006 international law forum du droit international and non state actors and international law have merged into a new journal. International law and armed nonstate actors in afghanistan. It is comprised of international treaties and customary law jus in bello is the body of legal norms that regulate the conduct of participants in armed conflict the international committee of the red cross icrc provides humanitarian protection of and assistance. Humanitarian actors must engage in dialogue with all parties to conflict for strictly humanitarian purposes. Why states comply with international law is often analysed through a combination of three key theories. It comprises individuals individuals in international law as well as entities, the latter spanning a large range of organizations and institutions on the global, regional, subregional as well as the local levels. The only book focussing on nonstate actors within the context of international humanitarian lawincludes chapters by both practitioners and scholars, thus combining theoretical discussions with the reallife challenges presented by nonstate actors in international humanitarian law. Jul 27, 2017 contemporary armed conflicts are characterised by an increase of violence against civilians and a lack of compliance with international humanitarian law ihl by both states and armed non state actors ansas.
International humanitarian law and the law of state responsibility revealed a comprehensive framework for determining accountability for violations committed during armed conflict, whether by state or non state actors. The status of private military companies in international law. In a security landscape characterised by the changing nature of armed conflicts and the proliferation of nonstate actors, the problem of the applicability and enforcement of international humanitarian law poses a number. Though there exists state and non state practice that suggests an opportunity to extend the combatants privilege to non state actors in a niac, there is not sufficient opinio juris to assert a change in customary international law. Applicability of international humanitarian law to non. Traditionally known jus in bello, the law of war, or law of armed conflict, the term. Cyber operations allow non state actors, with relatively minimal effort, to produce state level violence during armed conflict.
311 331 222 1335 771 448 1035 1186 317 628 1230 1303 114 828 48 770 151 615 1 253 464 160 152 844 842 1315 628 15 1101 1215 1069 977 843 12 271 1091 553